Skip to content
Conditions · Texture & Scarring

Types of Acne Scars: Ice Pick, Boxcar, Rolling and Raised

Not one condition. Icepick, boxcar and rolling scars have different architecture and respond to different things — which is why a single device rarely resolves a mixed face.

Book an assessment →
Acne Scars — assessed at IN Eternity Clinic Singapore
In short

There are three main types of depressed acne scars and one raised group. Ice pick scars are narrow and deep, boxcar scars are wider with steep walls and a flat floor, and rolling scars are broad waves tethered from below; hypertrophic and keloid scars are raised. Flat red or brown marks are not scars. Each type needs a different tool, as set out in acne scar treatment in Singapore. See also our guide to fungal acne. See also our guide to back acne.

Reviewed by Dr Sin Yong, Medical Director, IN Eternity Clinic · Updated
Key facts
  • What they are: permanent changes in the dermis after inflamed acne: collagen is lost (sunken scars) or overproduced (raised scars).
  • Three sunken types: icepick (narrow and deep), boxcar (wider, with sharp walls) and rolling (broad, soft undulations tethered from below).
  • Key clue: stretch the skin. Rolling scars soften when stretched; icepick and boxcar scars do not.
  • Why one device rarely suffices: each type sits at a different depth and needs a different action: release, resurfacing or focal treatment.
  • Marks are not scars: flat red or brown marks after acne are vessels or pigment, and fade or are treated differently.
  • When it waits: active inflammatory acne is controlled before scar work begins, because new spots make new scars.
  • Assessed by: Medical Director Dr Sin Yong at IN Eternity Clinic, 9 Scotts Road, Singapore.
Reviewed by Dr Sin Yong, Medical Director, IN Eternity Clinic · Last updated
What the research says
  • A global acne scarring grading system grades scars by severity so that the treatment, and the number of sessions, can be matched to the grade (Dermatol Surg 2006)
Figures taken from the published abstracts, checked against PubMed · Reviewed by Dr Sin Yong, Medical Director ·
At a glance

The types of acne scars at a glance

Acne scars are grouped by shape, because shape reflects how deep the damage went and what is holding the scar down. Most people have two or three types side by side.

Widths are typical ranges used in the published classification; real scars vary.
TypeShapeTypical widthStretch testMain page
Ice pickNarrow V-shaped shaft, deepUnder about 2 mmStays visibleIce pick scars
BoxcarSteep walls, flat floor; shallow or deepAbout 1.5–4 mmStays visibleBoxcar scars
RollingBroad, soft-edged wave, tethered from belowOften 4–5 mm or widerSoftens or flattensRolling scars and subcision
HypertrophicFirm raised scar within the original spotVariesNot applicableRaised scars
KeloidRaised scar growing beyond the original spotVaries; can enlargeNot applicableKeloid scars
Red or brown marksFlat; colour only, not a scarAnyNo change in contourPIE vs PIH
Illustration of acne scar types in a stylised skin cross-section: a narrow ice-pick pit, a flat-floored boxcar scar, a rolling scar tethered by fibrous bands, and a raised scar
Illustration of the main acne scar types in cross-section. Original illustration for IN Eternity Clinic.
Type by type

The main types of acne scars, one by one

Ice pick scars

Narrow and deep, like a puncture that runs into the dermis and sometimes down to the fat. They usually follow deep cysts and nodules, and from a distance look like large open pores. Because the opening is so narrow, little of the scar is exposed to the surface, which is why they are treated from the inside. See ice pick scar treatment.

Boxcar scars

Round or oval dips with steep, almost vertical walls and a flat floor. Shallow boxcar scars sit within about half a millimetre of the surface; deep ones go further. They form where inflammation destroyed collagen over a wider area than an ice pick scar. The sharp edge throws the shadow you see in side light. See boxcar scars treatment.

Rolling scars

Broad, shallow, soft-edged dips that give the cheek a wavy look. Fibrous bands join the underside of the skin to deeper tissue and pull it down, so they soften when the skin is stretched. Their cause sits below the surface, which is why release comes before resurfacing; see rolling acne scars and subcision.

Hypertrophic and keloid scars

Raised scars form when healing lays down too much collagen. Hypertrophic scars stay within the boundary of the original spot and may soften over a year or two; keloids grow beyond it, can itch or hurt and do not settle by themselves. Both are more common on the jaw, chest, shoulders and upper back, and keloids are more frequent in Asian and darker skin.

Mixed scarring and less common forms

Mixed scarring, with several types in the same area, is the rule rather than the exception. Less common forms include soft, skin-coloured papular scars on the chin and back, bridges and tunnels where skin heals over a tract, and small atrophic patches that look slightly thinned rather than pitted. They are named at assessment because they can need a different approach.

Tell them apart

How to tell which type of acne scar you have

  • Use side light. Stand by a window with light falling across your face, not straight on. Scars cast shadows; marks show only as colour.
  • Stretch the skin. Gently pull the skin beside a scar between two fingers. Rolling scars soften or flatten; ice pick and boxcar scars stay.
  • Look at the edge. Sharp walls suggest boxcar or ice pick; sloping edges suggest rolling.
  • Look at the width. A pinpoint opening suggests ice pick; a few millimetres with a flat floor suggests boxcar; a broad wave suggests rolling.
  • Feel the surface. A firm raised bump is a hypertrophic or keloid scar; a level surface with colour is a mark.

These checks give a first idea. A doctor’s assessment also measures depth, checks for tethering and separates scars from enlarged pores and marks, which is where most self-diagnosis goes wrong.

A Southeast Asian woman in her late twenties checking her cheek in a hand mirror by a window in soft side light, her whole head in frame
Illustrative image. Not a patient of IN Eternity Clinic.
Grading

How acne scars are graded

Doctors often describe severity with a qualitative global grading system that rates the whole face by how visible the scarring is at a normal social distance. It helps plan treatment and judge progress consistently.

Adapted descriptions of the Goodman and Baron qualitative grading system; the plan for you is decided at assessment.
GradeDescriptionWhat it usually means for a plan
1: MacularFlat red or brown marks; no change in contourMark treatment rather than scar treatment
2: MildShallow scars visible up close, easily covered by make-up or facial hairResurfacing or RF microneedling; a short course
3: ModerateScars obvious at social distance, not easily covered, flatten with stretchingCombination: subcision and resurfacing
4: SevereScars obvious at social distance, do not flatten with stretchingAll steps, often including TCA CROSS and volume support, over a longer course
Risk

Why some people scar more than others

  • Depth and duration of inflammation. Nodules and cysts, and spots that last weeks, destroy more collagen.
  • Delay before effective treatment. The longer inflammatory acne runs, the more scars form, so early treatment matters more than any later procedure.
  • Picking and squeezing. Pushes inflammation deeper and widens the injury.
  • Individual healing. Some people scar readily with modest acne, and scarring often runs in families.
  • Site. The jaw, chest and shoulders are more prone to raised scars; the cheeks and temples to depressed ones.

If acne is still active, treating it is the most effective scar prevention; see acne treatment in Singapore. In Asian skin, the same inflammation also tends to leave longer-lasting brown marks, explained in PIE vs PIH: red vs brown acne marks.

Mechanism

What is actually happening

Icepick scars are narrow and deep; boxcar scars are wider with sharply defined walls; rolling scars are shallow undulations tethered from below by fibrous bands.

The distinction

How it is told apart

Tethering is the distinction that changes the plan. A rolling scar is held down by a band; resurfacing the surface above it does very little. Release and resurfacing are not substitutes.

Assessment

What is established first

Scar type distribution, depth, tethering, active acne, Fitzpatrick type and prior treatment history.

Approach

What is typically done

Mixed presentations generally need combined approaches sequenced over time — release for tethering, resurfacing for texture, and pigment work where marks dominate.

When treatment waits

When it is deferred

Active inflammatory acne is controlled before scar work begins. Treating scars while new lesions form produces new scars.

In practice

How acne scars are treated at IN Eternity

The assessment grades each area of the face by scar type and depth, checks for tethering, records skin type and any active acne, and notes earlier treatments. Most people have a mixture, so the plan is built in layers rather than around a single device.

Tethered rolling scars are released first, by subcision. Boxcar and textured areas are resurfaced with the DEKA Tetra Pro CO2 laser (SCAR3) or fractional laser; deep icepick scars may need focal treatment. For mixed, deeper scarring these steps are combined in IN Eternity's 4D Scar Reconstruction protocol. The full range of options is set out on acne scar treatment in Singapore.

What to expect

Acne scar treatment: sessions, downtime and realistic change

Scar treatment is gradual. Collagen keeps remodelling for months after each session, so sessions are usually spaced four to eight weeks apart and progress is judged against photographs taken in the same light. Resurfacing sessions bring several days of redness and fine crusting; release and focal treatments may bruise.

In Asian skin the main risk is temporary darkening after treatment, which is reduced by sun protection in the weeks around each session, conservative settings and adequate intervals. The realistic aim is scars that are shallower and catch less light, not skin that has never been scarred.

“A rolling scar is held down from below. Resurfacing the top of it, however many times, will not release the band.”
— Dr Sin Yong, Medical Director, IN Eternity Clinic

Frequently asked

Can acne scars go away 100%?

Marks such as redness and brown spots after acne usually fade completely with time and care. True scars, where the skin is pitted or raised, do not disappear on their own and rarely go 100% even with treatment, but laser, RF microneedling, subcision and TCA CROSS can make them much less noticeable. Treating acne early prevents new scars.

What triggers acne scars?

Scars form when inflamed acne damages collagen in the deeper skin. Deep, cystic or long-lasting pimples, picking or squeezing, delayed treatment and a tendency to scar all increase the risk. Treating active acne early is the most effective prevention.

Can you get rid of acne scars?

Most acne scars can be made much less visible, though deep scars are rarely removed completely. Treatment depends on scar type: TCA CROSS for ice pick scars, subcision for rolling scars, fractional laser or RF microneedling for boxcar scars and texture. See acne scar treatment in Singapore.

What are acne scars?

Not one condition. Icepick, boxcar and rolling scars have different architecture and respond to different things — which is why a single device rarely resolves a mixed face.

How are acne scars told apart from similar conditions?

Tethering is the distinction that changes the plan. A rolling scar is held down by a band; resurfacing the surface above it does very little. Release and resurfacing are not substitutes.

What is assessed before treating acne scars?

Scar type distribution, depth, tethering, active acne, Fitzpatrick type and prior treatment history.

When is treatment deferred?

Active inflammatory acne is controlled before scar work begins. Treating scars while new lesions form produces new scars.

Can acne scars be removed completely?

Scars can usually be made shallower and less noticeable, but complete removal is not realistic. The amount of change depends on scar type, depth, skin type and how many sessions are done.

Which acne scars respond to laser alone?

Shallow boxcar scars and general texture often respond to resurfacing laser. Rolling scars usually need release first, and deep icepick scars often need focal treatment, so laser alone rarely covers a mixed face.

What are the types of acne scars?

The three main depressed types are ice pick (narrow and deep), boxcar (wider with steep walls and a flat floor) and rolling (broad waves tethered from below). Raised scars are hypertrophic or keloid. Flat red or brown marks are not scars.

Which type of acne scar is hardest to treat?

Deep ice pick scars, deep boxcar scars with a tethered floor and keloids usually need the most steps. Mixed scarring is also more involved, because each type needs its own tool. Shallow rolling scars and texture tend to respond more readily.

References

  1. Jacob CI, Dover JS, Kaminer MS. Acne scarring: a classification system and review of treatment options. J Am Acad Dermatol 2001;45(1):109-117. doi:10.1067/mjd.2001.113451
  2. Fabbrocini G, Annunziata MC, D'Arco V, et al. Acne scars: pathogenesis, classification and treatment. Dermatol Res Pract 2010;2010:893080. doi:10.1155/2010/893080
  3. Singapore Medical Council. Guidelines on Aesthetic Practices for Doctors (2016 edition). healthprofessionals.gov.sg/smc
  4. Goodman GJ, Baron JA. Postacne scarring: a qualitative global scarring grading system. Dermatol Surg 2006;32(12):1458-1466. doi:10.1111/j.1524-4725.2006.32354.x
  5. Kravvas G, Al-Niaimi F. A systematic review of treatments for acne scarring. Part 1: non-energy-based techniques. Scars Burn Heal 2017;3:2059513117695312. doi:10.1177/2059513117695312
  6. Abad-Casintahan F, Chow SKW, Goh CL, et al. Frequency and characteristics of acne-related post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation. J Dermatol 2016;43(7):826-828. doi:10.1111/1346-8138.13263

These sources describe mechanisms and general evidence. They are not a promise of any individual result; suitability is decided at an in-person assessment.

Have this assessed properly

Every assessment at IN Eternity Clinic is carried out personally by Medical Director Dr Sin Yong at 9 Scotts Road, #12-01 Pacific Plaza. If the honest answer is that treatment should wait, you will be told that.

WhatsApp the clinic →
← All conditions we assess
At a glance

Preventing acne scars, home care and treatment risks

How can acne scars be prevented?

The most useful step is to treat acne early and keep it controlled, especially deep painful spots and cysts, which are the ones most likely to scar. Avoid squeezing or picking, protect the skin from the sun so marks do not darken, and see a doctor if over-the-counter products have not helped within two to three months. Prescription treatment can reduce new scarring.

Can acne scars fade with creams or home care?

Red and brown marks after acne often fade over months with sunscreen and creams such as a retinoid, azelaic acid or vitamin C. True scars, where the skin is indented or raised, do not go away with creams alone because the collagen under the skin has changed. They usually need in-clinic treatment such as laser, RF microneedling or subcision.

What are the risks of acne scar treatment?

Common effects are redness, swelling and small scabs for a few days, depending on the treatment. Less common risks include temporary darkening of the skin, which is more likely in Asian skin, infection, cold sore flare and, rarely, new scarring. These are lowered by choosing settings for your skin type, preparing the skin and following aftercare closely.

WhatsApp us