Skip to content
Woman with softly defined cheekbones, illustrating Sculptra, Radiesse and Ellansé
Collagen Stimulators · Comparison · Orchard Road

Sculptra vs Radiesse vs Ellansé: Collagen Stimulators Compared

Three materials, one shared rule: plan before you place.

Poly-L-lactic acid, calcium hydroxylapatite and polycaprolactone all prompt your own collagen, but they behave differently on the day and over the months after. Dr Sin Yong explains the differences at IN Eternity Clinic on Orchard Road.

WhatsApp to Enquire →Key facts ↓
PLLA
Sculptra
CaHA
Radiesse
PCL
Ellansé
Not dissolvable
All three
Assessed and planned by Dr Sin Yong, Medical Director · MBBS (NUS) · MRCS (Edinburgh) · MSc Aesthetic Medicine (London) · MSc Practical Dermatology (Cardiff) · Professional Diploma in Obstetrics & Gynaecology (RCPI) · Designated DEKA Centre of Excellence
In short

Sculptra (poly-L-lactic acid) gives little immediate volume and builds collagen over months. Radiesse (calcium hydroxylapatite) gives firm structure on the day and can be diluted for skin firmness. Ellansé (polycaprolactone) gives support from its gel, then collagen forms around its microspheres. Each is a collagen stimulator that cannot be dissolved with hyaluronidase, so dosing is conservative.

Reviewed by Dr Sin Yong, Medical Director, IN Eternity Clinic · Updated
Key facts
  • Shared mechanism: each contains particles that the body recognises and walls off, prompting fibroblasts to lay down new collagen around them.
  • Sculptra (PLLA): poly-L-lactic acid microparticles reconstituted in water; early fullness fades within days and the lasting change develops over months.
  • Radiesse (CaHA): calcium hydroxylapatite microspheres in a gel; firm immediate support when undiluted, skin-quality use when diluted or hyperdiluted.
  • Ellansé (PCL): polycaprolactone microspheres in a carboxymethylcellulose gel; the gel gives initial volume and is replaced by collagen over weeks.
  • Reversibility: hyaluronidase dissolves hyaluronic acid only; it does not break down PLLA, CaHA or PCL.
  • Where they are not used: the lips and directly under the eyes, where firmer or particle-based products are more likely to be felt or seen.
  • Main risks: bruising and swelling; nodules, particularly with superficial placement; rarely, vascular complications as with any injectable.
  • Planning rule: existing filler is mapped with ultrasound first so new product is not layered on old.
Reviewed by Dr Sin Yong, Medical Director, IN Eternity Clinic · Last updated
Key facts · what the studies report
  • Sculptra: poly-L-lactic acid effects were reported up to 25 months in a randomised trial of 233 people. (Source: Narins 2010)
  • Radiesse: calcium hydroxylapatite was compared with a hyaluronic acid filler in a 12-month randomised split-face trial, and biopsies at six months showed new collagen around its microspheres. (Source: Berlin 2008)
  • Ellansé: the longer-lasting polycaprolactone formulation sustained improvement through a 24-month randomised trial. (Source: Moers-Carpi 2013)
  • Radiesse safety: a review of 5,081 calcium hydroxylapatite treatments found 173 adverse events, nearly all nodules, about half in mobile areas. (Source: Kadouch 2017)
  • Sculptra safety: papules and nodules were relatively common in early use of injectable PLLA and fell as preparation and technique improved. (Source: Bartus 2013)
Figures describe study groups, not individual results; numbers were checked against each source on 27 October 2026. Reviewed by Dr Sin Yong, Medical Director, IN Eternity Clinic ·
The shared idea

What is a collagen stimulator?

Hyaluronic acid fillers create volume mainly by holding water in a gel. Collagen stimulators work differently. They introduce small, biodegradable particles that the body treats as foreign material. Immune cells and fibroblasts gather around them and lay down new collagen, and the particles are then broken down slowly over time. What remains is tissue that you built yourself.

Sculptra, Radiesse and Ellansé are the three most familiar examples, made of poly-L-lactic acid (PLLA), calcium hydroxylapatite (CaHA) and polycaprolactone (PCL) respectively. They share that basic mechanism, and they share one important limit: none of them is dissolved by hyaluronidase. Where they differ is in how much they do on day one, how firm they are, and which jobs they are usually chosen for.

A woman reviewing her cheek contours in a hand mirror
Illustrative image. Not a patient of IN Eternity Clinic.
At a glance

Sculptra vs Radiesse vs Ellansé compared

SculptraRadiesseEllansé
MaterialPoly-L-lactic acidCalcium hydroxylapatitePolycaprolactone
Day-one volumeTemporary, from fluidYes, firmYes, from gel
Collagen buildGradual, over monthsOver weeks to monthsOver weeks to months
Typical usesTemples, cheeks, gradual volume lossNose, chin, jaw; diluted for skinNose, chin, temples, mid-face
DissolvableNoNoNo

The uses listed are typical, not fixed. Dose, depth and dilution decide what a product does in a particular face.

“With a product that cannot be dissolved, the most important skill is restraint. I plan for the collagen in three months, not the shape on day one.”
— Dr Sin Yong, Medical Director, IN Eternity Clinic
Sculptra

How Sculptra behaves

Sculptra arrives as a powder that is reconstituted with sterile water before use. When injected, the water gives a brief fullness that fades within days, which can make the first week look as if nothing has happened. The lasting change comes from collagen that develops around the particles over the following weeks and months, so it is given as a course of sessions spaced weeks apart, with massage advice afterwards to help even distribution.

Because the change is slow and diffuse, Sculptra suits broad, gradual volume loss: hollowing temples, a flattened mid-face, a lower face that has thinned. It suits people who want change that looks unforced and who are prepared to wait for it. It does not suit anyone who needs a defined shape by a fixed date, or areas that are already heavy with older product.

Ceramic bowls of powder, beads and gel representing three collagen stimulator materials
Illustrative image. Not a patient of IN Eternity Clinic.
Radiesse

How Radiesse behaves

Radiesse combines small calcium-based microspheres with a gel carrier. Undiluted, it is one of the firmer injectables, which is why it holds a line well when placed deep, close to bone, to project the nose, define the chin or sharpen the jawline. As the gel is absorbed, the microspheres act as a scaffold for new collagen.

Diluted or hyperdiluted with more liquid, the same product is fanned thinly under the skin of the face, neck or arms to support firmness. That is a different procedure with different expectations: it improves skin quality and does not change shape. Knowing which of the two jobs is wanted is the first decision, because it decides the dilution, depth and quantity.

Ellansé

How Ellansé behaves

Ellansé uses smooth polycaprolactone microspheres carried in a gel. The gel gives volume on the day; over the following weeks it is absorbed, and collagen formed around the microspheres takes over the support. Different versions of the product differ in how slowly the microspheres are broken down, which affects how long the result is expected to last.

Because support shifts from gel to collagen, the day-one look is not the end point, and Dr Sin Yong plans the dose around the expected collagen response rather than the immediate shape. Ellansé is used for structural areas: the nose, chin, temples and mid-face. For non-surgical nose shaping, he usually prefers a structural product such as calcium hydroxylapatite or polycaprolactone over hyaluronic acid alone.

Which suits whom

How Dr Sin Yong chooses between them

The question is first what the face needs, then which material fits. Broad, gradual volume loss where a soft, slow change is wanted often points to PLLA. A specific structural job, such as nose projection or a chin that needs to come forward, points to a firmer product such as CaHA or PCL placed deep. Skin that has thinned and lost firmness without any change in shape may suit diluted CaHA, or a skin injectable rather than a stimulator.

Before anything is added, existing filler is located with ultrasound. Many people who feel they need more volume actually have older product that has spread or been layered, and adding a collagen stimulator on top of that makes the face heavier. In that situation correction comes first. Because none of these products can be dissolved, quantities are kept conservative and sessions are reviewed before the next is booked.

After treatment

What to expect in the first weeks, and the risks

On the day, all three can leave swelling, tenderness and sometimes bruising at the injection points. With Sculptra, the face may look fuller for a few days as the water carrying the particles is still present; this settles, and some people feel the treatment has disappeared, which is expected. Massage instructions given at the clinic are followed for the days after, because they help the particles spread evenly.

With Radiesse and Ellansé, the shape is visible straight away, but swelling can exaggerate it for the first week. The area may feel firm. Over the following weeks the gel carrier is absorbed and collagen begins to form, and the feel softens towards that of your own tissue.

A review is booked several weeks after each session. Photographs taken in the same positions and light are compared, and the decision on whether to add more is made then, not on the day. This pacing is deliberate: with a product that cannot be dissolved, waiting to see the collagen response is the main safeguard against overcorrection.

Bruising, swelling and tenderness are common for a few days with all three. Nodules can form, more often when product is placed too superficially or in mobile areas, which is why they are kept out of the lips and directly under the eyes. As with any injectable, product entering a blood vessel is rare but serious, so anatomy, technique and an emergency plan matter. Signs such as sudden pain, blanching or a dusky patch need same-day attention.

These products are not used during pregnancy or breastfeeding, over active skin infection, or in people with a history of severe reactions to their components. Autoimmune conditions and a tendency to keloid scarring are discussed beforehand.

Evidence

Which collagen stimulator lasts longest in studies?

The studies are not head-to-head: Sculptra effects were reported up to 25 months, Ellansé-type PCL to 24 months and Radiesse in a 12-month trial, so they cannot be ranked by how long they last.

What the cited studies report, in brief. The studies are separate, not head-to-head; follow-up is the longest period studied, not a promise of how long any result lasts. Response varies between people and areas, and sessions are set at assessment.
Product (substance)How it worksWhen change showsWhat the cited studies reportUsual sessions
Sculptra (poly-L-lactic acid, PLLA)Particles prompt new collagen around them; little lasting day-one volumeGradually, over about three months after the last sessionEffects reported up to 25 months in a randomised trial of 233 people (Narins 2010)Often two or three, weeks apart
Radiesse (calcium hydroxylapatite, CaHA)Gel carrier supports on the day; microspheres then prompt collagenShape on the day; collagen over monthsA 12-month randomised split-face trial against hyaluronic acid (Moers-Carpi 2008); new collagen on biopsy at six months (Berlin 2008)Often one, with review; diluted plans may use more
Ellansé (polycaprolactone, PCL)Gel carrier supports on the day; microspheres then prompt collagenShape on the day; collagen over weeks to monthsImprovement maintained to 24 months with the longer-lasting formulation (Moers-Carpi 2013)Often one, with review
Juvelook (poly-D,L-lactic acid, PDLLA, with HA)Porous microspheres in the dermis prompt collagen; the HA hydrates brieflyOver weeks to months; early plumpness fades firstSafety follow-up to 24 months (No 2015); skin measures at six months in 15 women (J Med Assoc Thai 2025)Often two or three, four to six weeks apart

What the table does show is a shared pattern: each was followed for one to two years, each works through collagen, and none can be dissolved. In practice, longevity depends more on the area, the amount and the person than on the label, and a product that lasts longer is also one you live with longer. Juvelook is included because it belongs to the same polylactic acid family as Sculptra, but it is used in the skin rather than for volume.

Side effects and complications

What are the side effects and complications of Sculptra, Radiesse and Ellansé?

All three commonly cause swelling, bruising and tenderness for a few days; nodules are the main complication, and, unlike hyaluronic acid, none can be dissolved if a problem arises.

Typical patterns from the cited literature and clinical experience; individual risk depends on area, amount and technique.
Sculptra (PLLA)Radiesse (CaHA)Ellansé (PCL)
Early effectsSwelling, tenderness, bruising; early fullness fades within daysSwelling, tenderness, firmnessSwelling, firmness; can look fuller than planned for a week
Main complicationPapules and nodules, usually in the months afterNodules, mostly not visible, about half in mobile areasNodules, mostly with superficial or heavy placement
Late and rareInflammatory granulomas months or years laterPersistent inflammation or overcorrectionOvercorrection as collagen builds
If there is a problemTime, targeted treatment; cannot be dissolvedTime, targeted treatment; cannot be dissolvedTime, targeted treatment; cannot be dissolved

Because none of the three can be dissolved, prevention carries more weight than correction: earlier filler is mapped first, placement is deep, amounts are conservative and the result is reviewed before more is added. The Sculptra detail is in Sculptra side effects and safety; the four stimulators, including Juvelook, are compared in collagen stimulator side effects; lumps are explained in lumps after filler, and the full picture is on our filler complications hub.

When to act at once. If you notice blanching (skin turning pale or white), severe or increasing pain, mottled or dusky skin, or any change in vision after an injection, contact the treating clinic immediately. For any change in vision, go to the nearest emergency department. Do not try to treat it yourself or wait to see if it settles.

At IN Eternity Clinic, Dr Sin Yong performs injectable treatments himself, maps earlier filler with ultrasound where it is useful, and the clinic keeps an emergency protocol for vascular events, with hyaluronidase on hand for hyaluronic acid filler. How the clinic prepares is set out on safety and sterilisation.

Myths and facts

Common myths, answered

  • Myth: Collagen stimulators are just long-lasting fillers.
    Fact: They work by prompting your own collagen around biodegradable particles. Two of them give some day-one volume, but the lasting effect is the collagen.
  • Myth: If I do not like the result, it can be dissolved.
    Fact: Hyaluronidase dissolves hyaluronic acid only. PLLA, CaHA and PCL are not dissolved by it, which is why dosing is conservative.
  • Myth: Sculptra works straight away.
    Fact: The early fullness is water and fades within days. The collagen change builds over the following months.
  • Myth: More product means a better result.
    Fact: Overcorrection with a material that cannot be dissolved is hard to undo. Smaller, reviewed steps are safer.
Questions

Frequently asked questions

Which is better, Sculptra or Radiesse?

Neither is better in general. Sculptra builds collagen gradually and suits broad volume loss where a slow, soft change is wanted. Radiesse gives firm immediate support for structural areas such as the nose, chin and jaw, or can be diluted for skin firmness. Dr Sin Yong chooses after examining the face and mapping any existing filler.

What is the difference between Ellansé and Sculptra?

Ellansé is polycaprolactone microspheres in a gel, giving immediate support followed by collagen formation. Sculptra is poly-L-lactic acid with little lasting day-one volume, building collagen gradually over a course. Ellansé is often used for structure; Sculptra for gradual, diffuse volume. Neither can be dissolved with hyaluronidase.

Can these collagen stimulators be dissolved?

No. Hyaluronidase only breaks down hyaluronic acid. Poly-L-lactic acid, calcium hydroxylapatite and polycaprolactone are broken down slowly by the body on their own timetable. That is why quantities are kept conservative and the plan is reviewed before more product is added.

Which one is used for the nose?

For non-surgical nose shaping, Dr Sin Yong usually prefers a structural product such as calcium hydroxylapatite or polycaprolactone rather than hyaluronic acid alone, placed deep and in small amounts. Suitability depends on the nose, skin thickness and any previous procedures, which are assessed first.

How long do the results last?

It varies with the product, the version used, the area and the person. Collagen built in response to the particles persists for a time after the particles are broken down. Expected duration for your plan is discussed at consultation rather than promised in advance, because metabolism and lifestyle differ.

How much do Sculptra, Radiesse and Ellansé cost?

Cost depends on the product chosen, the number of syringes or vials needed, the number of sessions, and whether ultrasound mapping or correction of old filler is needed first. Dr Sin Yong gives a written quote after assessment that lists each part of the plan.

Can I have them if I already have filler?

Possibly, but the existing filler is mapped with ultrasound first. Layering new product on old is a common cause of heaviness. Where older filler has spread or sits in the wrong place, correction or waiting may come before any collagen stimulator is considered.

Which collagen stimulator lasts longest?

The studies cannot answer that directly, because none compared all three in the same people. Sculptra was followed up to 25 months, an Ellansé-type polycaprolactone to 24 months and Radiesse in a 12-month trial. In practice, the area, the amount, the version chosen and your own metabolism matter more than the label.

Which has fewer side effects: Sculptra, Radiesse or Ellansé?

None is clearly safer in general. All three share swelling, bruising and a risk of nodules, and none can be dissolved. Radiesse has the largest published safety review, with 173 adverse events in 5,081 treatments, nearly all nodules. Sculptra nodule rates fell as technique improved. Placement, dose and the doctor’s experience matter more than the product.

Which is used for hollow temples?

At IN Eternity Clinic, hollow temples are usually treated with Radiesse, placed deep, because it gives structure on the day and then prompts collagen. Sculptra is considered where a slower, broader change suits better, and hyaluronic acid where reversibility matters most. The anatomy and options are set out on temple filler in Singapore.

Which is used for the jawline and chin?

Usually a firm, structural product such as Radiesse or Ellansé, placed deep close to bone, because they hold a line well. Sculptra is less suited to defined points. A broad lower face from a strong masseter muscle needs a different approach, so the cause is assessed first; see jawline filler in Singapore.

Can Sculptra, Radiesse and Ellansé be combined?

Sometimes, in different areas or layers: for example a structural product at the chin and jaw, and Sculptra for broad volume loss at the temples or mid-face. Layering one directly over another in the same spot is avoided, and each step is reviewed before the next, because none of them can be dissolved.

Is Juvelook a collagen stimulator too?

Its PDLLA works as one, prompting collagen over months, and it belongs to the same polylactic acid family as Sculptra. But Juvelook is placed in the skin for texture and quality rather than deep for volume, so it is usually grouped with skin boosters. See Juvelook in Singapore.

Book an assessment

IN Eternity Clinic, 9 Scotts Road, #12-01 Pacific Plaza, Singapore 228210. By appointment with Medical Director Dr Sin Yong. Monday to Saturday, 11am to 8pm. WhatsApp or call +65 8815 3008.

WhatsApp to Enquire →Call +65 8815 3008
S
Dr Sin Yong
MBBS (NUS) · MRCS (Edinburgh) · MSc Aesthetic Medicine (London) · MSc Practical Dermatology (Cardiff) · Professional Diploma in Obstetrics & Gynaecology (RCPI)
International KOL — CLASSYS · HIRONIC · DEKA · ALMA · FOTONA · LUTRONIC

References

  1. Vleggaar D. Soft-tissue augmentation and the role of poly-L-lactic acid. Plast Reconstr Surg 2006;118(3 Suppl):46S-54S. doi:10.1097/01.prs.0000234846.00139.74
  2. Goldie K, Peeters W, Alghoul M, et al. Global Consensus Guidelines for the Injection of Diluted and Hyperdiluted Calcium Hydroxylapatite for Skin Tightening. Dermatol Surg 2018;44 Suppl 1:S32-S41. doi:10.1097/DSS.0000000000001685
  3. Christen MO, Vercesi F. Polycaprolactone: How a Well-Known and Futuristic Polymer Has Become an Innovative Collagen-Stimulator in Esthetics. Clin Cosmet Investig Dermatol 2020;13:31-48. doi:10.2147/CCID.S229054
  4. Berlin AL, Hussain M, Goldberg DJ. Calcium hydroxylapatite filler for facial rejuvenation: a histologic and immunohistochemical analysis. Dermatol Surg 2008;34 Suppl 1:S64-S67. doi:10.1111/j.1524-4725.2008.34245.x
  5. Kim JA, Van Abel D. Neocollagenesis in human tissue injected with a polycaprolactone-based dermal filler. J Cosmet Laser Ther 2015;17(2):99-101. doi:10.3109/14764172.2014.968586
  6. Narins RS, Baumann L, Brandt FS, et al. A randomized study of the efficacy and safety of injectable poly-L-lactic acid versus human-based collagen implant in the treatment of nasolabial fold wrinkles. J Am Acad Dermatol 2010;62(3):448-462. doi:10.1016/j.jaad.2009.07.040
  7. Moers-Carpi MM, Tufet JO. Calcium hydroxylapatite versus nonanimal stabilized hyaluronic acid for the correction of nasolabial folds: a 12-month, multicenter, prospective, randomized, controlled, split-face trial. Dermatol Surg 2008;34(2):210-215. doi:10.1111/j.1524-4725.2007.34039.x
  8. Moers-Carpi MM, Sherwood S. Polycaprolactone for the correction of nasolabial folds: a 24-month, prospective, randomized, controlled clinical trial. Dermatol Surg 2013;39(3 Pt 1):457-463. doi:10.1111/dsu.12054
  9. Kadouch JA. Calcium hydroxylapatite: a review on safety and complications. J Cosmet Dermatol 2017;16(2):152-161. doi:10.1111/jocd.12326
  10. Bartus C, Hanke CW, Daro-Kaftan E. A decade of experience with injectable poly-L-lactic acid: a focus on safety. Dermatol Surg 2013;39(5):698-705. doi:10.1111/dsu.12128
  11. No YA, Seok J, Hyun MY, et al. Long-term (24-month) safety evaluation of poly-DL-lactic acid filler injection for the nasolabial fold. Plast Reconstr Surg 2015;135(6):1074e-1075e. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000001247
  12. Effect of poly-D,L-lactic acid (PDLLA) biostimulator on facial rejuvenation markers in late middle-aged Thai women: a quasi-experimental study. J Med Assoc Thai 2025. doi:10.35755/jmedassocthai.2025.6.457-463-02252

These sources describe mechanisms and general evidence. They are not a promise of any individual result; suitability is decided at an in-person assessment.

WhatsApp us